Posts Tagged ‘Culture of Cruelty’

Justice for Nogales Teen Killed by Border Patrol

2 Comments | Share On Facebook| Justice for Nogales Teen Killed by Border Patrol Share/Save/Bookmark Nov 19, 2012

Memorial for José Antonio at a Day of the Dead Border Vigil in Nogales. (Credit: David Icely)

On the night of October 10, around 11:30 pm, José Antonio Elena Rodriguez, a 16-year-old resident of Nogales, Sonora, Mexico, was shot dead by a U.S. Border Patrol agent on Mexican soil. This tragedy hit home for me because José Antonio was killed on a street I know well in the border community where I live. But this incident is not unique. There have been 18 violent killings by Border Patrol or Customs and Border Protection agents since 2010—including a similar one in Nogales in January 2011. To my shame, I failed to raise my voice then.

The known circumstances of these killings strongly suggest unnecessary or excessive use of force. Please join me in denouncing them and calling for action.

The agent that killed José Antonio fired on him from atop a 25-foot embankment and from behind a 20-foot-tall protective steel border wall. José Antonio was shot in the back 13 times, with two bullets found in his head. He was unarmed. He died only a couple blocks from his house. These facts leave me with no doubt that this was an unlawful killing.

Six weeks have passed. The FBI, tasked with investigating the incident, has released no official statements, and has neither identified nor arrested the agent involved. The identities of officers involved in shootings are public information, and many in this border community, where I and other No More Deaths volunteers live and work, see José Antonio’s death as a clear case of bloody murder.

Please join me in urging the Department of Justice and the FBI to act transparently and decisively to end this unnecessary violence.

The excessive use of force that resulted in the deaths of José Antonio and 17 others is not the action of isolated “bad apples.” Rather, it is a consequence of the Border Patrol’s militarized approach to border enforcement, and it shows a callousness that is consistent with the findings of No More Deaths’ 2011 report Culture of Cruelty, which documented 32,075 incidents of mistreatment of migrants in Border Patrol custody.

We seek justice for José Antonio’s family and an end to these killings. Please take action and make your voice heard.

For justice and for peace,

David Hill
No More Deaths volunteer


The message above went out on Monday, November 19, 2012 to Standing on the Side of Love supporters. You can sign-up for these emails here.

Tell Napolitano: Stop Abuse by the U.S. Border Patrol

No Comments | Share On Facebook| Tell Napolitano: Stop Abuse by the U.S. Border Patrol Share/Save/Bookmark Jun 22, 2012

The message below went out on Friday, June 22, 2012 to Standing on the Side of Love supporters. You can sign-up for these emails here.


“I think there is the sense that it’s the border and that they’re ‘illegal.’ There’s this view that they aren’t supposed to be there, and they put themselves in the situation. Whatever happens to them they deserve. It’s hard to get sympathy or garner outrage over some of these cases.”

-Michelle Brané, Dir. of the Detention & Asylum program at the Women’s Refugee Commission, discussing the lack of mainstream media attention paid to U.S. Border Patrol abuse of migrants.

end_bp_abuseIn her “Prayer for Justice General Assembly,” Rev. Lilia Cuervo wrote, “Spirit of Justice, help us even in the middle of our busy lives to be clear that our work is not finished until those responsible for advancing and protecting migrants rights, effectively and conscientiously do so.”

This morning at our Justice General Assembly, in a workshop entitled “Culture of Cruelty: Documenting Human Rights Abuses Against Immigrants,” Standing on the Side of Love will join No More Deaths and Amnesty International to do just that—shine the light on Border Patrol abuse of migrants and discuss how the country’s largest law enforcement agency can be held more accountable.

Even if you aren’t in Phoenix this week, you can still speak out against this culture of cruelty. Click here to use our “Love in Action” Facebook app to send a message to Department of Homeland Security Secretary Napolitano.

Human rights organizations working at the border have found consistent patterns of Border Patrol abuse during detention and deportation. For example, the humanitarian organization No More Deaths documented 30,000 incidents of abuse from November 2008-March 2011. Since 2010, nine people have been reported killed or seriously injured in Border Patrol custody. While the Department of Homeland Security, under which Border Patrol falls, has internal oversight mechanisms, they are not preventing the kinds of abuse taking place. Independent observers are needed to monitor Border Patrol detention conditions.

Click here to take action and tell Secretary Napolitano that these human rights abuses must end.

It is imperative to give human rights advocates access to Border Patrol facilities. Only through outside monitoring—and independent oversight of Border Patrol from outside DHS—will the Border Patrol’s culture of cruelty truly change.

In faith,

meredith ga

Meredith Lukow
Program Assistant

Dan-Furmansky-cropped

Dan Furmansky
Campaign Manager
Standing on the Side of Love

No More Deaths Wins Wilton Peace Prize

No Comments | Share On Facebook| No More Deaths Wins Wilton Peace Prize Share/Save/Bookmark May 15, 2012

nmd_logo

No More Deaths/No Mas Muertes, an all-volunteer-led organization that embodies the very spirit of being the change one wishes to see in the world, has been chosen as this year’s recipient of the Wilton Peace Prize. The Wilton Peace Prize is given annually by the Unitarian Universalist Association (UUA) to individuals or groups in recognition of their contribution to “peace and human progress.” The award was established by Henry and Irene Wilton in 1984 and previous recipients include the Vietnam Veterans of America, Rep. Cynthia McKinney, and the World Council on Religion and Peace.

No More Deaths is a human rights and humanitarian aid organization that was first organized in 2004 with a simple mission to reduce deaths and suffering among migrants crossing the border through the Sonoran Desert. Since then it has expanded its work to meet the changing needs of undocumented immigrants and their families and to increase national awareness and draw attention to the enormous humanitarian crisis at the U.S.-Mexico border, where more than 6,000 innocent men, women and children have already died. No More Deaths is the social justice ministry of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Tucson and runs a number of programs including the Desert Aid Working Group, the Summer Desert Camps program as well as an Alternate Spring Break Camp in Arivaca, and the Abuse Documentation Working Group, which has been documenting human rights abuses by U.S. Border Patrol agents against migrants in their custody for the past six years.

According to a nomination letter written by Rev. Diane Dowgiert of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Tucson:

No More Deaths has contributed significantly to peace and human progress over the past eight years. Not only has this volunteer-driven humanitarian aid organization saved thousands of lives in the Sonoran Desert, giving water, food and medical care to displaced migrant workers forced to cross the most treacherous parts of the U.S.-Mexico border in search of jobs to provide for their families. No More Deaths has also spent the past six years documenting human rights abuses by the U.S. Border Patrol against thousands of migrants in their custody, both in the desert and in short-term immigrant detention centers.

culture_crueltyNo More Deaths has led the way in abuse documentation with its first report, “Crossing the Line,” in 2008, and has produced an outstanding second report, “A Culture of Cruelty,” providing high quality documentation of almost 30,000 instances of abuse from interviews with almost 13,000 migrants over a three-year period. They have set a national standard for the documentation of human rights abuses against migrants for subsequent reports by Amnesty International USA, the ACLU and other national human rights organizations across the country, who have sought out No More Deaths when beginning their research at the border.

In addition, through its “Keep Tucson Together” project, No More Deaths has been more successful than any other organization to date in helping local undocumented immigrant families stay together, by fighting to close the cases of inappropriate deportation orders sent to immigrant parents without any criminal record, whose children and spouses living with them in the U.S. are dependent upon them financially and emotionally.

Since the release of “A Culture of Cruelty” on September 21, 2011, the report has also received coverage from CNN, USA Today, Reuters News Service, Democracy Now and many other news outlets. No More Deaths will receive a $1,500 donation from the UUA to support its efforts.

Thank you, No More Deaths, for your incredible work for human rights, and a better world for all people.

I would like to nominate No More Deaths/No Mas Muertes, the social justice ministry of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Tucson, for the Wilton Peace Prize this year.  This amazing, volunteer-run human rights and humanitarian aid organization was first organized in 2004 with a simple mission to reduce deaths and suffering among migrants crossing the border through the Sonoran Desert.  Since then it has expanded its work to meet the changing needs of undocumented immigrants and their families and to increase national awareness and draw attention to the enormous humanitarian crisis at the U.S.-Mexico border, where more than 6,000 innocent men, women and children have already died.
During the past eight years, No More Deaths has expanded its scope to include:
the Desert Aid Working Group, which provides water, food, clothing and a medical tent to treat injuries and dehydration-related illnesses of migrants crossing the border.  This year there have been several volunteers working with migrants in the desert throughout the winter months as well.
the Summer Desert Camps program as well as an Alternate Spring Break Camp in Arivaca, where hundreds of young adult volunteers come each year to be trained about border history, politics, legal issues and first aid so that they can reach out to save more lives in the desert through hands-on, experiential learning.
an Abuse Documentation Working Group, which has been documenting human rights abuses by U.S. Border Patrol agents against migrants in their custody for the past six years.  Its first report, “Crossing the Line”, was published in 2008, and made the human rights community aware of the horrific human rights abuses, and even torture, committed by Border Patrol agents.  Following that report, the ACLU of Arizona and other human rights organizations began to consult with No More Deaths and issue their own reports on human rights abuses at the border.
In September, 2011, No More Deaths issued a far more extensive report, “A Culture of Cruelty:  Abuse and Impunity in Short-Term U.S. Border Patrol Custody.”  This report was based on statistical compilations of interviews with more than 12,000 migrants over a three-year period in Nogales, Naco and Agua Prieta, Sonora, Mexico, finding and categorizing about 30,000 specific instances of human rights abuses.  This report, which strongly demonstrates that these human rights abuses by Border Patrol are systemic and must be dealt with systemically, includes numerous recommendations, including the need to demand access to immigrant detention facilities s by human rights organizations to investigate conditions and treatment of migrants held there, and the need for an independent oversight agency comprised of citizens and human rights organizations to investigate abuses, with the power to enforce human rights standards and discipline agents who violate those standards.
The “Culture of Cruelty” report (online at www.nomoredeaths.org/cultureofcruelty.html), with the help of the UUA’s Standing on the Side of Love and the UU United Nations Organization, has opened many new doors for No More Deaths.  They were honored with a rare invitation to testify about the report at hearings on March 27, 2012, before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights of the Organization of American States in Washington, D.C.  They also gave presentations before the U.N. NGO Commission on Human Rights, the U.N. High Commissioner on Human Rights, and a Congressional briefing in Washington, D.C., as well as at a meeting with a White House policy advisor.  And they will give a workshop presentation on “A Culture of Cruelty” on June 22, 2012, at the UUA Justice General Assembly in Phoenix, along with Amnesty International USA and Standing on the Side of Love.
the Nogales/Mexico Project Working Group, based in Nogales, Sonora, Mexico.  There No More Deaths volunteers has worked since 2006 to provide humanitarian aid to individuals deported from the U.S. to cities along the border.  NMD works in partnership with multiple humanitarian, faith-based and governmental organizations in Northern Sonora and has partnerships in two border communities, Nogales and Agua Prieta. In 2011 almost 55,000 people were deported though Nogales from all over the U.S.  No More Deaths volunteers currently support between 60-120 people a day making phone calls to their families back home, successfully retrieving missing personal belongings confiscated by law enforcement to around 30 people per month, and helping about 50 people a month reconnect with family members separated in deportation. They also provide first aid and medical care at the Mexican Grupos Beta offices, in partnership with the Jesuit-based Kino Border Initiative.
the “We Reject Racism” campaign against Arizona SB 1070, partnering with the immigrant rights group Tierra y Libertad Organizacion.  ”We Reject Racism” was a campaign to sign on small businesses in Tucson to publicly oppose SB 1070 and to educate the community with information, store signs and yard signs.
the “Keep Tucson Together” campaign, to fight separation of immigrant families through deportation.  NMD’s “Keep Tucson Together” volunteers are fighting the deportation orders that were sent to 50 Tucson undocumented immigrants who have no criminal record, and whose spouses and children are either U.S. citizens or have legal residency or visas, and depend upon them for financial and emotional support.  No More Deaths has already succeeded in getting many of these deportation cases administratively closed through a campaign of public activism, media team work and social witness, in conjunction with the legal services of No More Deaths Atty. Margo Cowan.
Below please find media coverage of No More Deaths activities.  As the Media Coverage of No More Deaths shows, No More Deaths has set the standards for high quality research and documentation of human rights abuses by the U.S. Border Patrol against migrants in their custody.  Since that time the ACLU of Arizona, Amnesty International USA, PBS “Frontline” documentary “Lost in Detention” and the media have supported our findings.  Interview requests from the media have greatly increased, with the latest request coming from the BBC to interview NMD volunteers who work on the Mexico side of Nogales with just-deported migrants.

Congress: Do Your Part to End Border Patrol Abuses

1 Comment | Share On Facebook| Congress: Do Your Part to End Border Patrol Abuses Share/Save/Bookmark Nov 16, 2011
NMD congressional briefing

Panelists: Jennifer Podkul from the Women's Refugee Commission, Tania Chozet from the ACLU of New Mexico, and Danielle Alvarado from No More Deaths.

Yesterday afternoon advocacy organization representatives and congressional staffers gathered in a small room in the Canon House Office Building for a congressional briefing on No More Deaths’ “Culture of Cruelty” report.  As we have reported previously (here and here), No More Deaths conducted interviews with nearly 13,000 migrants and documented 30,000 incidents of abuse and mistreatment by the U.S. Border Patrol in short-term detention over the course of three years. At the briefing, Danielle Alvarado from No More Deaths, Jennifer Podkul of the Women’s Refugee Commission, and Tania Chozet from the ACLU of New Mexico’s Regional Center for Border Rights each spoke about their experiences working with migrants near the border and their frustration surrounding the Border Patrol’s flat out denial of the report’s findings.

While the report presents a multitude of alarming statistics about the situation on our southwestern border (for example: “out of 433 incidents in which emergency medical treatment or medication were needed, only 59 (14%) received it before being deported – the other 86% were deported without receiving needed medical care”), yesterday’s briefing focused on the actions that members of Congress can take to alleviate the situation.

Despite the report’s disturbing findings, the Border Patrol has been unwilling to meet with No More Deaths locally.  This is not an isolated incident–Customs and Border Patrol (CBP) has a reputation for being unresponsive to both civil society and congressional information requests.  The only existing oversight mechanism–the Department of Homeland Security Office for Civil Rights & Civil Liberties (CRCL)–is understaffed, does not have the authority to issue penalties or make binding recommendations, and is not independent enough to truly hold the agency accountable.  Consequently, no one is asking questions about questionable Border Patrol policies.

In contrast, Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has introduced access policies to allow advocacy groups to visit their detention facilities and conduct independent monitoring.  This program allows ICE to benefit from the expertise and advice of the advocacy community as well as fosters dialogue about ICE policies.  This model could provide similar accountability for Border Patrol policies and facilities.

The panelists emphasized that they are not asking that the laws go unenforced, just that they be carried out in a humane way.  This kind of abuse and mistreatment is inexcusable, particularly in the United States of America.  Moreover, though these policies are conducted under the guise of national security, human rights abuses do not make us safer.  Congress can do a number of things to hold the Border Patrol accountable for their actions including adding oversight and reporting conditions in budget bills and calling for oversight hearings.  Our members of Congress need to start asking the tough questions and requiring the executive agencies to take responsibility for the abuses occurring on their watch.

——————————————————————————————————————–

Want to do something about Border Patrol abuse?  Sign our petitionCall the White House and ask the administration to launch an investigation.  Contact your members of Congress and ask them to call for an oversight hearing.  Make your voice heard!

President Obama: Take Decisive Action Against Border Patrol Abuses

2 Comments | Share On Facebook| President Obama: Take Decisive Action Against Border Patrol Abuses Share/Save/Bookmark Nov 15, 2011

The message below went out to Standing on the Side of Love supporters on Tuesday, November 15, 2011. You can sign-up for these emails here.

——————————————————————————————————————–

Wounded knee

Knee injury sustained from a fall while being chased by Border Patrol, subsequently denied medical care. This man was deported having only received newspapers to bandage what agents called “just a scratch” to mock him, laughing.

I can’t thank you enough.  At the end of September, my organization, No More Deaths, released “Culture of Cruelty,” a report that painstakingly details abuses of migrants by the U.S. Border Patrol. After interviewing 13,000 people and documenting 30,000 incidents of abuse, we hoped that people of conscience would take a stand. Thousands of you signed a petition to President Obama, urging him to intervene against systemic abuse perpetrated by the nation’s largest federal enforcement agency. You also wrote letters to the editor to your local papers and made phone calls to Border Patrol.

As a result of your advocacy, No More Deaths got the chance to speak directly with the Administration yesterday. Our delegation met with White House advisors to show them the extent of the abuse, and the Border Patrol leadership’s alarming inability to control their agents. We shared our stories, and we gave the White House a simple message: You can end this now.

March 15, 2010 interview with Jorge, 27, from Guatemala

Six Border Patrol agents, including some on horses and motorcycles, surrounded his group of 10. He was thrown onto the ground face first and an agent hit him on the side with the butt of a gun while agents yelled insults. Jorge was held for three days in the Tucson processing center. When he repeatedly asked to see a doctor, he was denied. Agents threw out any food the detainees had and provided none even when it was requested; over the course of three days, they received only packets of crackers. Jorge now suffers chronic stomach pain as a result of going so long without eating. Border Patrol also took everyone’s clothes except a t-shirt and pants and then turned on the air conditioning. Jorge says his belongings, including his birth certificate and $100 U.S. currency, were confiscated and not returned. Jorge has a cousin and father who live in Santa Monica, Calif., where he lived for 10 years before being deported. He was apprehended by Border Patrol as he attempted to return to them.

And we’re not stopping there. Today we are on Capitol Hill, educating Congress about the disturbing daily reality along the border. We will be calling for independent oversight of the Department of Homeland Security and an end to the increases in border and immigration enforcement that tear our families apart. Before we return to Arizona we’ll meet with international human rights organizations, national immigrant and border advocates, and key partners in the fight for justice and dignity for all.

In just a few hours we will meet with Customs and Border Protection. They’re hoping this will all go away. You helped ensure that the human rights abuses outlined in our report won’t be forgotten.

As exciting as all this is, the hard truth is that nothing has changed – yet. Now that we have the attention of the White House and Border Patrol, it’s crucial for you to weigh in again and let the Administration know that meetings aren’t enough – it’s time for direct, decisive action.

Please call the White House today and help us deliver three key messages:

(1) Thank you for meeting with No More Deaths and immigrant rights groups and sending a message that you are concerned about Border Patrol abuse.

(2) Please urge the Department of Justice to launch an investigation into the widespread abuse being perpetrated by Border Patrol.

(3) The Department of Homeland Security cannot monitor itself. Please establish an independent oversight mechanism outside of DHS to hold Border Patrol agents accountable.

Call the White House Today:
Phone Numbers
Comments: 202-456-1111

TTY/TTD
Comments: 202-456-6213

Friends, Border Patrol abuses reach far beyond Arizona and affect us all. When we allow anyone to be mistreated, we send the message that discrimination and cruelty are acceptable. These abuses fly in the face of justice, accountability and what’s morally right.

On behalf of No More Deaths, I offer many thanks to the Unitarian Universalist Association Funding Program and the Standing on the Side of Love Campaign for supporting the work of No More Deaths, and this report.  And I thank you for your commitment to a world where all people are treated with basic dignity and respect.

In partnership,

Danielle Alvarado
Author, “Culture of Cruelty”